11 November 2026
Having a hernia in each groin and having a hernia that has returned are different situations. In the first, we need to decide how to address two defects. In the second, we need to understand a previous repair and work with anatomy that has already changed. Both need a more detailed assessment than simply choosing a technique by name.
If you have been told that your hernia is bilateral or recurrent, it helps to come to the consultation with two questions: what has been confirmed on each side, and what do we know about previous operations?

For a hernia that has already been operated on, the previous report helps establish which repair was performed. AI-generated illustration; it does not depict real people or clinical outcomes.
Bilateral hernias: two sides that may cause different symptoms
A bilateral hernia means there is a hernia in each groin. One side may hurt more, only one lump may be visible, or the second hernia may have been found during examination. Symptoms in each groin are assessed separately, alongside the size and behaviour of each hernia and its effect on your activities.
Discomfort on both sides does not, by itself, confirm a bilateral hernia. Nor does every small finding on a scan require immediate repair. The question is whether there is a defect and how relevant it is for that person.
If a second hernia was not evident before surgery and is identified during the operation, the decision should not be improvised without discussing that possibility beforehand. Examination of the other groin and any potential treatment form part of the information and consent process where appropriate.
Can both hernias be repaired in one operation?
In suitable patients, a bilateral repair can be performed during the same operation. Laparo-endoscopic approaches allow both groins to be treated through shared access incisions and have an important role in this situation, provided there is an appropriate indication, experience and resources.
This does not mean that all bilateral hernias should be repaired in the same way. Previous surgery, suitability for general anaesthesia, the characteristics of each hernia and the patient's general health all influence the decision. Prostate surgery or other pelvic operations, for example, may make dissection of certain tissue planes more complex.
A useful discussion covers what is proposed for each side, why, and which circumstances might lead to a change of plan. It should also cover risks and the expected recovery in relation to your activities.
Two situations, two starting questions
| Situation | Starting question |
|---|---|
| Bilateral hernia | What is present in each groin, and should both be treated in one operation? |
| Recurrent hernia | What was repaired before, in which tissue plane, and what is causing the symptoms now? |
Recurrent hernias: first confirm what has returned
A recurrence is the return of a hernia after a repair. It may appear as a new lump, a feeling of pressure or discomfort during physical effort. Even so, pain or a bulge in a previously operated groin does not, by itself, prove that the hernia has recurred.
Scar tissue, a seroma and other causes of pain can produce similar symptoms. Assessment combines the history, examination and any necessary investigations. Distinguishing these situations matters: operating again on a painful area without clarifying the cause may not solve the problem.
It is also important to know when the change began and how it has developed. A problem that appears soon after surgery raises different questions from a lump that develops many years later.
The document that may make the biggest difference to the consultation
The previous operation report shows whether the repair was open or laparo-endoscopic, which tissue plane was used, whether mesh was placed and what difficulties were described. The external scar does not always reveal all these details.
If you have the implant identification details, these may also help. If you do not have the documents, explain where and when you had surgery so that they can be requested. Not knowing the name of the technique does not prevent assessment from starting.
Imaging can add to this information, but not all materials show equally well and not all anatomical relationships can be clarified in one investigation. The operation report and the images provide different information.

A proposed repeat operation should explain how previous surgery affects the plan and which alternatives are available. AI-generated illustration; it does not depict real people or clinical outcomes.
Why a different approach is sometimes proposed
An operation leaves scars and changes the tissues in the plane where the surgery was performed. In some recurrent hernias, approaching from another plane avoids part of the area already dissected. This is one of the principles that guides planning, not a rule to apply without knowing the case.
In general, guidelines recommend a posterior approach after a failed anterior repair and an anterior approach after a failed posterior repair. If both planes have already been operated on, there have been several recurrences, or other problems are present, the decision needs particularly careful assessment by a team experienced in these situations.
Previously placed mesh is not automatically removed because a hernia has recurred. Keeping or removing it depends on specific problems and objectives, and removing an implant may add complexity and risks. It is a separate decision from repairing the new defect.
How good planning helps set expectations
Preventing recurrence and persistent pain matters in a first repair; these remain central aims in a repeat operation, but the starting point is different. It helps to distinguish what is expected to improve — the lump, pain related to movement or activity limitations — from symptoms that may have another cause.
Ask about the possibility of changing the approach, the alternatives if difficulties arise, and the planned follow-up. A laparoscopic or robotic technique is a tool within the plan; it does not, by itself, guarantee freedom from pain or further recurrences.
When planning recovery, describe the actual tasks involved in your work and sport. Having had an operation before does not mean the next recovery will follow the same course.
When not to wait for a routine review
A previously repaired hernia can produce the same warning signs as a primary hernia. Severe, persistent pain, a lump that no longer goes back in as it usually does, vomiting or abdominal swelling require urgent medical attention. Do not force the lump back in.
The consultation should result in a plan that explains both sides, or the recurrence, with your previous history taken into account. This understanding helps you make decisions with realistic expectations.
Further reading
To learn about treatment options, read the inguinal hernia guide. If you need an assessment, request a consultation with Dr Pablo Aragó. The Contact page explains the options at IMED Valencia, IMED Colón and Gandía. For urgent symptoms, seek emergency care.
This is general information and does not replace an individual assessment.
Medical sources
- HerniaSurge: 2023 international update
- International guidelines: recurrent hernias, chapter 20 of the English summary
Supporting reference: Novitsky YW (ed.). Hernia Surgery, 2nd edition, 2025. Preoperative imaging, patient preparation and assessment of problems after hernia repair. Original patient information; the images in this draft were not taken from the book.

